Loading…
Икигай (японское «предназначение») и Maslow's Hierarchy отвечают на разные вопросы о том, как жить хорошо. Сравнение: происхождение, основная идея, временной горизонт и результат.
Maslow's Hierarchy is a developmental theory: humans satisfy lower-order needs (food, safety, belonging) before pursuing higher ones (esteem, self-actualization). Ikigai is a structural theory: a meaningful life is the intersection of four dimensions held simultaneously — what you love, what you're skilled at, what the world needs, and what you can be paid for. Maslow asks "which need is currently blocking me?" Ikigai asks "are my four pillars aligned?"
Пять осей, по которым две концепции действительно различаются — а не только в лозунгах.
| Ось | Икигай (Япония) | Maslow's Hierarchy (American psychology) |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Japanese everyday philosophy, popularized globally in the 2010s. | Proposed by Abraham Maslow (1908-1970) in his 1943 paper "A Theory of Human Motivation." His late writings on self-transcendence were published posthumously. |
| Structure | Four overlapping circles. No order — all four must meet for Ikigai to exist. | Five-tier pyramid (physiological → safety → belonging → esteem → self-actualization). Lower needs typically prerequisites for higher ones. |
| Core question | Where is the intersection of love, skill, contribution, and earning? | Which needs are currently unmet, and which must I satisfy before pursuing the next? |
| Evidence base | Sone et al. (2008) followed 43,391 Japanese adults for 7 years; those reporting ikigai had significantly lower all-cause mortality. | Heavily cited across psychology and management theory. The strict hierarchical ordering is debated; modern researchers often treat the tiers as overlapping rather than sequential. |
| Where it leads | A current life-shape that integrates four dimensions simultaneously. | A staged progression toward self-actualization — a top-of-pyramid destination. |
Maslow tells you what you need to climb; Ikigai tells you where to point once you're climbing. They sit at different layers, not on opposite sides. A useful sequence: use Maslow's frame to triage what's missing, then use Ikigai's frame to choose your direction. If you suspect you're already past the first three tiers and the question is "toward what?", our free Ikigai test is the right next step.
8 минут. Без регистрации. Более 50 000 пройденных.